No. A/90643/XII(9)/Sub.Comm/Merger/DGQA/ADM/JCM
10 Oct 2013
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE
(DGQA/ADM/JCM)
JCM SUB-COMMITTEE FOR MERGER OF TECHNICAL/SCIENTIFIC AND DRAWING STAFF.
Reference DGQA/ADM/JCM note No. A/90643/XII(9)/Sub.Comm/Merger/DGQA/ADM/JCM dated 15 Jul' 10.
2. The report of the JCM Sub-Committee for merger of Technical, Scientific and Drawing Staff is enclosed for information and necessary action.
sd/-
(S.Alagesan)
Director (Pers)
Member Secretary
No A/90643/XII(9)Sub-comm/Merger/DGQA/ADM/JCM
10 oct 2013
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE
(DGQA/ADM/JCM)
REPORT OF THE JCM SUB-COMMITTEE FOR MERGER OF TECHNICAL, SCIENTIFIC AND DRAWING OFFICE STAFF.
Background
Vide Order bearing No. A/90643/XII(9)/Sub.Comm/Merger/DGQA/ADM/JCM dated 15 Jul' 10, a Committe was constituted with the approval of DGQA to study the feasibility for the merger of Technical/Scientific and Drawing Office staff and to make it as one common cadre. The Committee comprised of 06 Staff Side Members and 04 Official Side Members, the Chairman and the Secretary of the Committee being from the Official Side.
2. The Staff Side Members were requested to make specific suggestions with regard to the modus operandi of such merger to put the deliberations of the Committee on the fast track. The suggestions where duly made. In pursuance of the demand of Staff Side to associate representatives of NGOs and Scientific Associations with the Committee, it was decided by the competent authority that if the Chairman of the Sub-Committee considers it appropriate, opinion/views/suggestions from other recognized Associations of DGQA (other that whose rep is already member in JCM Sub-Committees) may be invited through Leader and Secretary Staff Side and taken into consideration while finalizing the report of the ibid JCM Sub-Committee. This was greed to by the Chairman. Subsequently, the Scientific Workers Association made available its views through the Secretary Staff Side for consideration of the Sub Committee.
3. Cadre Structure of the Technical Scientific and Drawing Staff:
| Sl No | PAY BAND &GRADE PAY | TECHNICAL SUPERVISORY CADRE | SCIENTIFIC CADRE | DRAWING OFFICE CADRE |
| 1 | PB-2 9300-34800 GP 4600 | JUNIOR TECHNICAL OFFICER since redisgnated ASSISTANT ENGINEER (QA) (66.67% by Promotion & 33.33% by DR) | JUNIOR TECHNICAL OFFICER(S) (100% by Promotion) | JUNIOR TECHNICAL OFFICER(D) (100% by Promotion) |
| 2 | PB-2 9300-34800 GP 4200 | CHARGEMAN since redisgnated as JUNIOR ENGINEER(QA) (100% by DR) | SCIENTIFIC ASSISTANT (100% by DR) | SENIOR DRAUGHTSMAN (50% Promotion & 50% DR) |
| 3 | PB-2 5200-20200 GP 2400 | Nil | Nil | DRAUGHTSMAN (100% by DR) |
4. Educational Qualifications:
| Sl no | TECHNICAL SUPERVISORY CADRE | SCIENTIFIC CADRE | DRAWING OFFICE CADRE |
| 1 | JTO since redisgnated as AE(QA) for DR M.Sc. or B.E. with two years experience | JTO(S) Not relevant as induction is by Promotion | Not relevant as induction is by Promotion |
| 2 | C'MAN since redisgnated as JE(QA) For DR - B.Sc. or Diploma in Engineering with one year experience | SA For DR - B.Sc. or Diploma in Engineering with two years experience | Sr. D'MAN for DR - Diploma in Engineering |
| 3 | Nil | Nil | D'MAN For DR Matriculation along with Certificate Course or Diploma in Draughtsmanship of not less than two years duration (including six months practical training). |
5. Observations of the Committee: The Committee noted that the number of grades have been considerably reduced consequent to the recommendations of the VI Central Pay Commission. Study of the cadre structures of the Technical, Scientific and Drawing Office Staff reveals that the Technical and Scientific Cadres have been reduced to two-grades in the Grade pay of Rs.4600 and Rs.4200 whereas the Drawing Office Staff has three grades with Grade Pay Rs.4600, Rs.4200 and Rs.2400. The first two grades in the three streams have same grade pay and comparable educational qualifications/qualitative requirements for appointment to the grades as shown tables at paras 4 and 5 above. It is accepted that the merger of posts with same grade pay in three cadres into single cadre would greatly enhance the functional utilization of manpower and also better management of a single unified cadre instead of three. Merger of these equivalent grades in the three streams into one common cadre does not involve any administrative or procedural problem. After merger the grades would require a common designation and the question of inter se seniority in the merged grade would be dealt with by application of the principle of continuous officiation in the respective grades prior to merger.
6. Consequent to merger of JTO(D) (GP Rs.4600) and Sr. D'Men (GP Rs.4200) with equivalent grades in Technical and Scientific Cadre posts there is a lower grade of D'Men-III in the grade pay of Rs.2400 in the Draughtsmen cadre. As against the authorization of 119 posts of D'Men-III there are only 12 incumbents in the grade. It is considered that these individuals may be inducted into the higher grade depending on their educational qualification and service in the grade.
7. The committee, therefore, recommends that the posts of AE(QA), JTO(S) and JTO(D) in the grade pay of Rs. 4600 be merged and redesignated AE(QA) and the posts JE(QA), Scientific Assistant and Dr Draughtsman in the grade pay of Rs. 4200 be merged and redesignated as JE (QA). The inter-se seniority be fixed as DOP&T guidelines regarding continuous officiation in equivalent grades. The incumbents in residual category of D'Man-III in the grade pay of Rs.2400 be inducted into the higher grade and the post of D'Man-III be abolished.
8 This has been adopted in the last meeting of the sub committee on 26.09.13
sd sd
(M K R Pillai) (Brig. MD Singh)
Leader Staff side JCM III Level DDG (Stores
sd Member
sd
(HN Tiwari) A Anbarsan
Secretary Staff SIDE JCM III Level DDG(A)
Member
sd sd
(P Mohan rao) S Alagesan
Rep bpms JCM III Level Dir(pers)
Member Secretary
sd
(Denny Issac)
Rep of AIDEF JCM III Level
sd
(Amose Prabhakar)
Rep of CDRA JCM III Level
sd
Sanjeev Kapoor
ADGQA(S)
Chairman
Source:http://bpms.org.in/documents/dgqa-merger-45ad.pdf
